A Few (Really Annoying) Eskimo Rolling Myths

Here are some Eskimo rolling myths you may hear at some point in your beginner whitewater kayaking journey. If you do, just tell the person talking that “I’ve read the blog post, so I know that what you’re saying is complete otter spittle.” Or something like that. ;)

Myth 1. “You will lose your roll at some point.”

No you won’t, not if you keep practicing it and are tough on yourself as far as always trying to have the best possible technique.  Don’t be afraid to be an advanced boater who still starts out a pool session doing hip snaps at the side of the pool.  Many of the good Class V boaters I know have gone through periods during which they’ve struggled with their roll, that’s pretty normal – but you don’t have to lose it.

Myth 2. “You shouldn’t be flipping over.”

Flipping and (hopefully) rolling are just part of kayaking, unless you are always on flat water or paddling way below your skill level.  Trying new things and (gasp) failing occasionally is part of the fun, or should be.  Don’t let people make you feel bad about it.  Of course as you learn to brace better you’ll flip less, and as you get into harder whitewater flipping (and especially not rolling up) become more consequential, but most people who push themselves even a little bit are going to flip at some point, whether it’s on Class II or Class V. The people who are most severe about it tend to be very stylish paddlers who don’t think you should try anything unless you’re almost sure to crush the line, or more timid boaters who often don’t have a great roll themselves.  Wish them well, don your nose plugs, and carry on.

Myth 3. “The roll requires strength.”

No it doesn’t.  OK, you have to be able to hold a paddle and rotate your torso, but that’s basically it as long as your technique is correct.  Being flexible will actually help your roll a lot more, so it’s worth doing stretches that increase your ability to bend sideways.

Myth 4. “Your roll is getting sketchy?  You just need some river time.”

Umm, no.  Yes, it’s true that playboating and doing things that make you flip a lot can be super helpful in terms of teaching you how to combat roll in all kinds of positions and river situations, but if your roll is shakey to the point that you’ve started getting nervous and your technique is deteriorating then you probably need flat water time, not river time.  Being scared that you’re not going to make the roll makes you more likely to pull your head, which makes you more likely to miss your roll, etc. etc.  It can be difficult but extremely useful to step back a pace or two and give yourself a chance to re-solidify your technique without the additional stress of doing it in moving water and/or having to making it upright before a downriver feature.

Myth 5. “Using the extended (Pawlata) paddle roll to learn the Eskimo roll is cheating.”

No, it isn’t, not if you use it as a training tool, just like a gymnast uses a suspension harness as a tool to let their body learn the correct body mechanics for a tumbling or balance bar routine. (You don’t see those harnesses in the Olympics, right? The harness was a training tool that helped that person get to the Olympics. Why is this concept so hard for some people to relate to? But I digress.)

Using the extended hold on the blade gives you much more leverage and makes it easier to roll, which means that instead of worrying about whether you’re going to make the roll in the first place (which causes people to pull their head, try to power up, thrash around  and overall learn bad form) you greatly increase the chances of making the roll and now you can work on your technique. (It’s pretty darn hard to work on your rolling form when you can’t roll up to begin with. Also, this learning technique can be very helpful for those people who are teaching themselves to roll and don’t have someone there to help roll them up.) Once you’re comfortable and rolling up beautifully, then little by little start moving your hands down the shaft, keeping great form, until you’re rolling normally with great form. If your technique starts to slide, just move your hands back to the extended position, get yourself back in the groove of having the right technique, then start moving your hands back to normal position again. This may take hundreds of rolls. If so, awesome! Muscle memory is your friend.

I’m not saying the extended paddle roll is the only way to learn the roll, many people develop a great roll using other learning methods, but it’s how I learned and it really worked – I was known as the beginner boater with the bomber roll (normal hand position) starting out because I worked on my technique with hundreds of pool rolls, going back to the extended blade hold to re-focus whenever things got shakey.  Having a good roll enabled me to push myself on harder stuff early on (probably a bit too much, but that’s another post), and it really, really bothers me when I see new boaters starting out and someone – usually either a super good paddler who learned it differently, or else someone with a bad roll (go figure) – has told them the extended paddle roll technique is ‘cheating’. I’ve seen these beginners tough it out and power out a bunch of shakey pool rolls with the normal hand position because they want to do the right thing and not ‘cheat’, and some of them I’ve seen still struggling with their rolls years later, even to the point of eventually pretty much bagging kayaking. Which is why I find Myth 5 really, really annoying.

Also, please keep in mind that being tired can cause you to miss rolls, which is another reason playboating and river time (see Myth 4) aren’t the fix for 100 percent of situations. Mike, super solid Class V boater who runs 50/50 and the Box Canyon of the Ashlu (see his lovely line on 50/50 below), swam in an eddy on Boulder Drop on the Skykomish last month because he had hiked his boat up three times and raced Boulder Drop 3 laps and was just extremely tired.  It kind of gives hope to the rest of us. ;)

You may also want to check out the Beginner Kayaking Tips – Forward Stroke post – Michele Ramaza’s video tutorial on the forward stroke is excellent. Having a strong and effective forward stroke is absolutely crucial to progressing in whitewater kayaking and it’s probably the most under-taught and under-practiced skill on the river. (Not the fault of beginner kayakers, they have no reason to realize how important this is and for some reason most of the time no one tells them.)

Irene
 

Callum - December 16, 2016

Great article, which i totally agree with, especially myths 3,4 & 5. for smaller paddlers especially, fitting their boat is the most important thing, after that technique, strength is way down the list – i’ve taught small girls to roll faster than grown men, because they concentrate on the technique whereas the men will try to use brute strength. If you are becoming sketchy with your roll, practice, if the water getting up your nose bothers you get a nose clip, being able to roll is a vital skill -if you don’t practice it will become sketchy! Finally the pawlata, as any pilot will tell you, any landing you can walk away from was a good one, the same with a roll, its the simplest, and gives new paddlers confidence on which they can build very quickly, once you can pawlata, you can usually eskimo/screw roll within half an hour -especially if your learning in a pool. (just remember to flick them hips!)

Irene - December 16, 2016

“Any landing you can walk away from is a good one” – I hadn’t heard that before, good analogy. :) Now that you mention it, I don’t think I’ve talked about outfitting in any of my roll troubleshooting posts, and that is a huge point. Loose boat or having to stretch to feel the footblocks makes things incredibly hard and most beginners don’t know that either, I know I didn’t!

John - December 24, 2016

I agree with everything except about the extended paddle roll. As a beginner, I was taught this technique as well, and while it certainly got me running rivers quicker, I feel that it taught me poor rolling technique that I had to work very hard to unlearn. How did that happen? By extending your paddle, you get a HUGE amount of leverage to right your boat. So much leverage, in fact, that you can roll up while lifting your head up first. Which is the muscle memory that stuck with me and had to be unlearned before I could roll with my hands in the normal position.

Anyhow, just another opinion on this subject. What works for some does not work for all!

Irene - December 28, 2016

Hi John, thanks for your comment, I probably should have specified more in the post that the point of using the Pawlata roll is to allow the paddler to perfect their technique – in other words, I would never tell a paddler who was pulling their head on the extended paddle roll to go out and use it on a river, that would be like letting a gymnast go into competition using their suspension harness. If someone is pulling their head on the Pawlata roll they probably won’t be able to roll up with a regular grip, period. However, if that is the case, that means they are at least getting a roll with the Pawlata method without swimming or needing someone to assist them, which means they can work on their roll again and again with some help from the leverage so that they work towards perfect technique with the Pawlata grip. Once technique has gone from head-pulling to perfect with the Pawlata roll, then they can move the hands down so that the passive hand (the left hand for most right-handers) is at the base of the paddle shaft and repeat the road-to-perfection process – going back to the Pawlata to reestablish good technique if they start flailing. That’s what I did and I know what works for some doesn’t work for all, so I’m not saying it’s the best approach for everyone, but my point is that if the Pawlata roll is used the goal is never for it to be an entry point for bad technique, it’s meant to be the opposite by allowing people to work on their technique without the stress and flailing that can cement bad technique when people use only the traditional hand grip to learn the roll and they’re barely making it up each time. I’ve seen so many people who were taught that the Pawlata roll was cheating and who stayed timid and insecure about their bad-technique, muscled-up traditionally taught rolls for years (for good reason), thus really taking away from the enjoyment of kayaking, that I feel pretty strongly about it. :)

Comments are closed